
Friar Pedro Clubs El Maragato with the Butt of the Gun
Historical Context
Friar Pedro Clubs El Maragato with the Butt of the Gun shows the decisive moment of physical reversal in Goya's six-panel narrative — the friar, who has wrested the gun from the bandit, now uses it as a club to subdue his opponent. The physical violence depicted here was unusual for Spanish sacred art, which rarely showed clergymen as protagonists in scenes of hand-to-hand combat. Goya's treatment is direct and unsentimental, the friar's action shown as effective and brutal without heroic idealization. The series' combination of religious subject with earthy physical comedy reflects the picaresque tradition in Spanish culture that celebrated the cunning of the powerless over the powerful.
Technical Analysis
The violent action is captured with bold, dynamic brushwork that conveys the force of the blow. Goya's composition creates a powerful diagonal movement across the small panel, with the figures's interlocked forms expressing physical struggle. The dark palette is punctuated by sharp highlights on the weapon and the friar's robe.
Provenance
One of a series of six small paintings in an inventory of Goya’s collection, Madrid, taken in 1812 for the division of property between the artist and his son Javier following the death of the artist's wife; the group of small paintings marked X8 being allotted to the son: "Seis quadros del Maragato señalados con el número ocho, en 700 [reales]" (the inventory mark has been removed from the painting and is no longer visible) [see Gassier and Wilson 1971]; presumably Javier Goya after 1812. Lafitte collection, Madrid; sale, Paris, Hôtel Drouot, March 7, 1861, bought in together with other paintings from the series for 590 francs [see Hippolyte Mireur, Dictionnaire des ventes (Paris, 1914), vol. 3, p. 360 and Despartment Fitz-Gerald 1928-1950]. Julius Böhler, Munich by 1911; sold to Martin Ryerson (died 1932), Chicago in May 1911 [see purchase receipt dated May 13, 1911]; bequeathed to the Art Institute, 1933.







.jpg&width=600)